Rebuilding after swapping hard drive?

I have four 20TB Exos drives and one 20TB IronWolf drive which was added after the four Exos. I want to replace the IronWolf with another 20TB Exos. Can I just shutdown the DS1522+, pull the IronWoft, replace it with the new Exos and it will rebuild whatever was on the IronWolf? Since the IronWolf was added last, a few weeks later, one of the Exos would have been used for the RAID drive.

All five drives are currently a single Synology volume RAID 5 and, so far, only 15TB total have been written to them. I also have two 2TB nvme RAID 1 read/write cache (Btrfs pinned) and wonder how that would be affected. Would I need to remove it first, assuming the HD swap works?

Thanks

You can swap the disk as you mentioned. After powering on, go into Storage Manager to start rebuilding the storage pool.

You are strongly encouraged to make a full backup before starting the process.

Thanks Paul. Do I need to delete the cache first and create a new one after?

Deleting and recreating the cache is not required, but it’s good advice to be on the safe side.

Thanks. It occurred to me that it might be wise to pause backup tasks, too.

Before pulling the drive it is good practice to:

  1. Run a file scrub to correct any possible file corruption
  2. Ensure your daily off-NAS backup is current

Personally, I would leave things alone unless the IW drive is showing signs of failure.

I’ve decided to leave the drives as they are. Every 8-10-16 TB Seagate Expansion external usb drive I’ve purchased has had an EXOS but the 20TB just delivered contained a Barracuda and was purchased directly from Seagate. I expected to get another EXOS but it wasn’t my lucky day.

The NAS is the backup of my Plex server which is currently being moved from Windows 10 to a Mac M4 in a 5-bay drive enclosure.